3.5 Stars
This novel has a unique narrative style: it’s written as a series of statements and interviews for a documentary.
The Sharaf family, originally from Afghanistan, lives in an exclusive neighbourhood of Virginia. They arrived with nothing, but Rahmat Sharaf worked hard and managed to become very successful and wealthy. The tight-knit family seems to be living the American dream. When Zorah, the eldest daughter, dies tragically, the family comes under scrutiny. Are they the model immigrant family or are there dark secrets behind a facade?
The statements are made by relatives, friends, neighbours, teachers, investigators, and lawyers. Media stories are included. The only people who do not speak directly are the members of the Sharaf family. This approach is intentional so readers must come to their own conclusions about the culpability of Rahmat and Maryam and their eldest son Omer.
Readers will find themselves changing their opinions several times. New information emerges and differing opinions are expressed, and the reader must consider conflicting perspectives. Certainly when thinking about the statements of various people, it’s important to realize that views are skewed by loyalties, jealousies, rifts, and biases.
The judgments made of the Sharafs are often influenced by cultural differences. Many in the Afghan community think, for example, that Zorah was given too much freedom and didn’t follow Islamic values, becoming too assimilated into American culture. On the other hand, Zorah’s friends think she was trapped by a strict family whose restrictions and punitive measures bordered on abusive.
The title is perfect. All the speakers try to portray themselves as good people. They emphasize how their behaviour was admirable, though objectively one might question their real motivations. What is also obvious is that for the Afghan community, “name is everything. The beginning and end. Once my good name is lost, it’s lost forever.” Women, in particular, must protect a family’s honour: “If a boy does a bad thing people will talk a little, but in the end a man’s faults are always hidden,” but “a girl’s reputation is like a cloth of pure white. The tiniest fleck of dirt – the tiniest fleck of dirt anywhere – and the whole thing is ruined.” One newspaper article stresses that in Afghan culture “a family’s honor is inextricably bound to the virginity of its unmarried women and the ‘virtue’ of its married women.” There is no doubt that Zorah’s behaviour sullied the family’s reputation. The central question is whether the family did something “to free itself of social censure and reclaim their lost honor”?
The author states that the novel “was inspired by true events” but “is not a retelling of any one case.” Unfortunately, my reading of the book was heavily influenced by the 2009 Shafia family case which bears many similarities to events in this novel. Some cursory research suggests that this case, involving a submerged car in a canal lock after a family trip to Niagara Falls, was definitely used. I have no problem with writers being inspired by real events, but since I was familiar with the details of the Shafia family case, my interpretation of the events in the novel was coloured by knowing the outcome of the Canadian story which occurred not too far from where I live.
Though the book touches on serious themes like immigration, cultural expectations, racism, misogyny, and Islamophobia, its narrative style makes it a fast read.






