Ranked a Top Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Monday, November 16, 2026

Review of GOOD PEOPLE by Patmeena Sabit

 3.5 Stars

This novel has a unique narrative style: it’s written as a series of statements and interviews for a documentary.

The Sharaf family, originally from Afghanistan, lives in an exclusive neighbourhood of Virginia. They arrived with nothing, but Rahmat Sharaf worked hard and managed to become very successful and wealthy. The tight-knit family seems to be living the American dream. When Zorah, the eldest daughter, dies tragically, the family comes under scrutiny. Are they the model immigrant family or are there dark secrets behind a facade?

The statements are made by relatives, friends, neighbours, teachers, investigators, and lawyers. Media stories are included. The only people who do not speak directly are the members of the Sharaf family. This approach is intentional so readers must come to their own conclusions about the culpability of Rahmat and Maryam and their eldest son Omer.

Readers will find themselves changing their opinions several times. New information emerges and differing opinions are expressed, and the reader must consider conflicting perspectives. Certainly when thinking about the statements of various people, it’s important to realize that views are skewed by loyalties, jealousies, rifts, and biases.

The judgments made of the Sharafs are often influenced by cultural differences. Many in the Afghan community think, for example, that Zorah was given too much freedom and didn’t follow Islamic values, becoming too assimilated into American culture. On the other hand, Zorah’s friends think she was trapped by a strict family whose restrictions and punitive measures bordered on abusive.

The title is perfect. All the speakers try to portray themselves as good people. They emphasize how their behaviour was admirable, though objectively one might question their real motivations. What is also obvious is that for the Afghan community, “name is everything. The beginning and end. Once my good name is lost, it’s lost forever.” Women, in particular, must protect a family’s honour: “If a boy does a bad thing people will talk a little, but in the end a man’s faults are always hidden,” but “a girl’s reputation is like a cloth of pure white. The tiniest fleck of dirt – the tiniest fleck of dirt anywhere – and the whole thing is ruined.” One newspaper article stresses that in Afghan culture “a family’s honor is inextricably bound to the virginity of its unmarried women and the ‘virtue’ of its married women.” There is no doubt that Zorah’s behaviour sullied the family’s reputation. The central question is whether the family did something “to free itself of social censure and reclaim their lost honor”?

The author states that the novel “was inspired by true events” but “is not a retelling of any one case.”  Unfortunately, my reading of the book was heavily influenced by the 2009 Shafia family case which bears many similarities to events in this novel. Some cursory research suggests that this case, involving a submerged car in a canal lock after a family trip to Niagara Falls, was definitely used. I have no problem with writers being inspired by real events, but since I was familiar with the details of the Shafia family case, my interpretation of the events in the novel was coloured by knowing the outcome of the Canadian story which occurred not too far from where I live.

Though the book touches on serious themes like immigration, cultural expectations, racism, misogyny, and Islamophobia, its narrative style makes it a fast read.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Review of THE MAN WHO READ BOOKS by Rachid Benzine (New Release)

 3.5 Stars

This novella describes the lives of Palestinians since the creation of Israel in 1948.

In 2014, Julien Desmanges is sent to Gaza to photograph the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. During a ceasefire, he comes across a bookseller, an elderly Palestinian surrounded by stacks of books. When Julien asks the man, Nabil Al Jaber, if he can take his photo, Nabil responds that Julien must get to know him first. Over the next few days, Nabil tells his life story: his birth in 1948 to a Muslim mother and Christian father, his family’s displacement during the Nakba, his growing up in a series of camps, and his adult life. Included throughout are references to books which helped Nabil to understand the world and to survive.

The book is narrated in second person point of view. I imagine the author’s intention with this choice is to help the reader feel s/he is part of the narrative. Unfortunately, I’m not a fan of this perspective. I find it artificial and it just becomes annoying after a while.

The situation of Palestinians is highlighted: “The economic exploitation, the restrictions on movement, the unemployment, the poverty, . . . total dependence on the occupier, the expanding colonies, the absolute absence of any political breakthrough that might offer . . . hope.”

Obviously, the book is also about the power of literature. Nabil speaks of how books let him escape: “’We were all in the same place, still embroiled in our poverty and suffering, but for a few hours we were transported elsewhere.’” Literature provides a human connection: “’To read is to enter into the minds of others, to be with them, to find yourself in their words.’”

The subject matter is so important; what is happening in Gaza needs to be understood in light of events over the last 78 years. In a letter to the reader, the author explains that his purpose is to forge a connection and emphasize our shared humanity. Unfortunately, the style sometimes made me feel I was reading a report rather than a novel: “’On the night of the thirty-first of December 1947, Balad al-Sheikh was purged of its Arab inhabitants by the Palmach, an arm of the Haganah’” and “’Israeli Military Order No. 50, issued on the eleventh of July 1967, was basically a list of all our stolen rights.’” (Readers unfamiliar with groups like the Palmach, the Haganah, and the Irgun may feel overwhelmed.)

This is not an easy read. Nabil speaks of his people being locked in a struggle since 1948, a struggle to which there is no end in sight. He ends his story by describing himself as being “’lost in this absurd, inhuman world, with all its rage.’” Though short, the book is emotionally impactful.

Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Review of WHALE HARBOR by Mary Beth Keane (New Release)

 3.5 Stars

This novel, about the Joyces, an Irish family of eleven brothers, begins in 1963 and spans the next forty years.

A tragedy causes the family to be split apart. Macdara, the second oldest at 16, is offered a job on a Montana cattle ranch and he sets off. A younger brother, 9-year-old Rian, begs to come along and Macdara promises to bring him to the US once Rian is old enough. Four years later, Rian disappears; people suspect that he has run away. It’s that disappearance that haunts the brothers, especially Macdara, for decades.

The relationship between Macdara and Rian is wonderfully depicted. Rian is a spirited, curious child who follows his older brother like a shadow. When Macdara leaves, there’s a heart-breaking scene of Rian running after the car. Because Macdara doesn’t keep his promise to his brother, he is wracked by guilt when Rian disappears.

Macdara’s relationship with his father Cathal is complicated. Macdara has difficulty accepting many of the decisions Cathal makes and blames him for breaking up the family. It is interesting to see Macdara’s growth as he navigates different stages of his life. His perspective of others, including his father, changes over time. For instance, when Macdara becomes a father, he realizes that as a parent, he had no idea what he was doing: “Who ever knew what they were doing, what was best, until after the fact?” It is only later in life that Macdara realizes he never considered things from his father’s perspective; he focused on his feelings at leaving his family, but Lillie tells him to consider how parents felt when children left.

It’s also interesting to see Macdara realize that his brothers remember events differently. Depending on their ages when an event occurred, they may in fact have no memory of something that to Macdara is unforgettable. Macdara resents Nuala, but his younger brothers have an entirely different opinion of her.

The author must be given credit for making the brothers distinct enough that it is not difficult to remember who is who. What is lacking, however, is tension. Especially in the middle, the book reads more like a summary of marriages and births with large gaps. I found this section slow. The ending is not entirely satisfying because, though there is a resolution of sorts, there are unanswered questions.

Initially this book reminded me of Whale Fall by Elizabeth O’Connor – a whale washes up on shore and the community is subjected to the stench of a rotting carcass. Then there’s the arrival of people wanting to study the community and using the language skills of a young person. From these similarities however, the books go into entirely different directions and, though the whale is a symbol in both, it symbolizes entirely different ideas.

The novel tells an engaging story which emphasizes how being an adult means being able to understand behaviour from another person’s perspective and accepting that decisions which might initially have seemed cruel or irrational may in fact have been well-intentioned.

Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Friday, November 6, 2026

Review of MADELINE MCKNIGHT SIGNS OFF by Evan Brooke (New Release)

 4 Stars

This novel, both funny and heart-breaking, reminded me of The Correspondent by Virginia Evans.

Madeline McKnight, a former Wall Street analyst, has terminal cancer. She contacts Bri Davis, the daughter of her estranged best friend, and asks her to care for her at the end of her life. In return, Madeline promises Bri 2 million dollars. Bri, a nursing student drowning in debt, takes the job. When she arrives, she learns Madeline wants her help with her unusual bucket list. An unconventional relationship develops.

The book has an interesting format. Perspective alternates between Madeline and Bri, but also included are tables, equations, information graphics, and annual reports, all elements appropriate to Madeline’s background.

The unusual relationship between the women ends up changing them both. Both learn about themselves and what is most important to them.

I loved Madeline. She’s a feisty curmudgeon who will “not go gently into that good night.” She’s intelligent, stubborn, determined, and ambitious. Forced to confront her mortality, she learns her flaws and regrets. She comes to acknowledge the complexity of human beings, both her own and that of Hetty Green, her heroine. The two had both accomplishments and failures. I came to respect Madeline more and more as I learned the obstacles she faced: in the male-dominated financial investment world, misogyny was rampant in the 80s and 90s.

Though there is sadness, the overwhelming message is positive and life-affirming: personal growth and meaningful connection are possible at any stage of one’s life.

I recommend this novel because I think it has something for everyone.

Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Review of SOLACE IN WINTER by Mary Lawson (New Release)

4.5 Stars 

Having read and loved all four of Lawson’s previous novels, I was excited to read her latest.

The novel is set in 1969 in northeastern Ontario, the setting of all of Lawson’s books. Jack Gallagher comes across the aftermath of two accidents in the course of a few days. First he finds a dog which was hit by a vehicle and then he rescues Chris Hansen, an American draft dodger very seriously injured in a car accident. Jack, a widower who loves his solitude, has his life upended when his cabin is filled with a recovering dog and human and various others who come regularly to help. Unfortunately, visits by Jack’s daughter Sally complicate rather than help.

Besides Jack and Chris, there are a number of characters whom the reader gets to know. There’s Tomas, the town vet who often serves as a doctor; Kurt, the lone policeman in Solace; Ellie, Kurt’s wife and the nurse who helps care for Chris; and Sally, Jack’s daughter. Backstories, complete with hopes and disappointments, are provided for all. Chapters alternate among characters. Since the omniscient point of view is used, the reader becomes privy to their thoughts and feelings.

This is a novel about ordinary people living ordinary lives who are brought together by extraordinary circumstances and build unexpected connections. They are strangers who become “not strangers, brought together by pure chance and finding common ground.” These connections end up changing lives. Jack, for instance, realizes “he craved peace and solitude less fervently than he had.”

Family dynamics are explored. Chris’ relationships with his father and mother are described. And then there’s the difficult relationship between Jack and Sally. What I appreciate is that even characters whom the reader will probably not like are not caricatures. Sally, for instance, is angry, bitter, and jealous, but Jack acknowledges that he and his wife Hannah had not been good parents and had not shown or expressed their love for their daughter as they should have. Hannah, a renowned textile artist, had been so focused on her work that she had time for little else. As a result, though I hated Sally’s behaviour, I did have some sympathy for her.

The author uses an understated style. Much is said in few words. For example, when Chris is visited by Patrick, Jack notices that his smile “was not a smile but a mask for grief” but that Chris is blind to his friend’s pain and the reason for it. Remembering this observation, though nothing is ever said, one cannot but wonder about Patrick’s fateful decision later in the book.

The novel has a very strong sense of place. Having lived in northeastern Ontario for many years, I can attest to the accuracy of the landscape descriptions. The descriptions of snow, both its beauty and the hardships it causes, bring back memories. The cabin, a haven from the cold, feels welcoming and serves as a place of healing.

There are wonderful touches of humour. Jack’s initial interactions with Lola, the dog, are moments of levity. His demonstrating to Lola how to urinate on newspaper has him concluding that “she probably thinks I’m some sort of pervert.” And Jack’s exchanges with the slippers-wearing waitress at the local café are wonderful.

Lawson’s books rank among my all-time favourites. I highly recommend this one as I have recommended all of the others.

Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Friday, October 30, 2026

Review of SWEET PEA by Kit de Waal (New Release)

 3.5 Stars

This novel, under its UK title, The Best of Everything, appeared on the longlist for the 2026 Women’s Prize for Fiction.

The novel is set in Birmingham, England, over a span of 20 years beginning in 1972. Paulette, an immigrant from St. Kitts, is 29 when the novel opens. She works as an auxiliary nurse. She has a man in her life, Denton Fitzpatrick, whom she hopes to marry and with whom she hopes to have a family. When Denton dies in an accident, her dreams come to an end. Garfield, Denton’s best friend, tries to help her through her grief and eventually they become a couple. They have a son named Bird. Then Paulette meets Frank, the man responsible for the accident which took Denton’s life. She learns that he is struggling to care for his grandson Nellie. Slowly she brings Nellie into her family and has two boys to care for. Of course Paulette’s life is not without difficulties and sometimes her life spirals out of control.

This is very much a novel of characters and Paulette is the central figure. She is a complex character which makes her very realistic. She is kind and compassionate as evidenced in her actions towards Frank and Nellie. She loves her son more than anything, giving him the best of everything she can afford. The problem is that she needs his presence to give her life purpose and meaning. When Bird is away spending time with his father, she thinks only of his return. This of course becomes more of a problem as Bird grows up. She takes solace in drinking.

What also stands out is her poor choices when it comes to men. When Denton dies, she learns that he had a life about which she knew nothing. It’s obvious that he didn’t love her as she loved him, yet she spends years pining for him. Years later, she still believes, “If Denton hadn’t have been snatched from the earth, her life would have run along different tracks, smooth and straight.” Knowing Denton’s secrets, it’s obvious Paulette is deluding herself. After Denton she has a string of affairs with married men; one poor choice follows another. She’s obviously lonely, but she seems a poor judge of character when it comes to men.

She has a blind spot when it comes to Bird as well. Her friend Maggie tells her that “’Bird’s had the wool pulled over your eyes since he was a baby. You think the sun shines out of his arse but he’s as selfish as they come and loves himself into the bargain.’” Paulette’s friendship with Maggie suffers because Paulette is too stubborn to admit that there is some truth in Maggie’s comments. She also, like most humans, does not see herself very clearly. She is angry at Frank because he tells the story of the accident “with himself right plum in the centre” as if he were the victim. She never acknowledges that she does the same, not fully considering that there are many victims.

Paulette does experience growth. The kindness she gave is not forgotten and she is helped to find her way. She learns that she does not need others to give her life purpose; she can find a purpose for herself. In the end one can only cheer for this deeply human character.

The novel touches on a number of serious topics: grief, motherhood, the immigrant experience, and raising a black son in a predominately white society with systemic racism. Nonetheless, most readers will find the ending satisfying.

Note: I received an eARC from the publisher via NetGalley.

Monday, October 26, 2026

Review of NO SONG FOR THE DEAD by Jussi Adler-Olsen, Stine Bolther, and Line Holm

 3.5 Stars

This is the 11th Department Q novel but with a difference: Jussi Adler-Olsen has co-written it with two journalists.

Since Carl Mørck has retired to write books and is no longer head of Department Q, a new transfer is added to the team of Assad and Rose. Helene Henry doesn’t really want to be there and has secrets about her past she doesn’t share with her colleagues. Carl brings them an audio recording that has the team re-opening a case that four years earlier had been deemed a suicide after an attempted murder.

Other crimes are also investigated, all connected to a prestigious school and its boy choir and events there thirty years earlier. As expected, all the crimes end up being connected. The point of view of the perpetrator is given throughout so the reader knows the motives for the various crimes. In fact, the prologue makes much obvious from the beginning, especially that a childhood trauma has had long-lasting consequences. Will the team be able to identify the perpetrator and stop him?

This didn’t really feel like the old Department Q novels which I enjoyed. Carl is largely absent and I missed the relationship between Carl and Assad. In addition, I didn’t care for Helene. She has too many secrets; in fact, it’s difficult to understand how she is allowed to continue working in a police department. Obviously there will be a sequel to fill in her mysterious past.

What I actually enjoyed the most is that I was travelling through Denmark as I read this book, and I visited many of the places used as settings in the novel.