Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Sunday, October 6, 2019

Review of FINDERS KEEPERS by Stephen King

3 Stars
This is the second book of the Bill Hodges Trilogy beginning with Mr. Mercedes.

In 1978, Morris Bellamy invades the home of John Rothstein, a novelist famous for a trilogy of books featuring Jimmy Gold.  After killing Rothstein, Morris and his two partners steal money and dozens of notebooks which may hold more Jimmy Gold novels.  Morris is unhappy with Gold’s fate in the third novel and hopes Rothstein has written more about him.  Morris buries the money and notebooks in an old chest for temporary safekeeping but ends up in prison with a life sentence for another crime. 

Thirty years later, 13-year-old Pete Saubers, who lives in Morris’ childhood home, discovers the chest.  He uses the money to help his family which has struggled financially after his father was injured in the attack carried out by the Mercedes killer.  Pete reads the notebooks and, like Morris, falls in love with them.  What should he do with them?  Should be sell them to get more money?

The story alternates between Pete and Morris’ stories in both the past and present.  The reader knows that the two will meet somehow.  Bill Hodges, the retired police detective, is brought into the story when Pete’s sister becomes concerned about his strange behaviour.  Bill and his partners, Jerome and Holly, discover that Pete is in danger and needs their help.

Morris Bellamy is a problematic villain.  He has absolutely no redeeming qualities.  Then there’s his obsession with the fate of a character in a series of books.  He feels such an attachment to Jimmy Gold that he experiences sociopathic rage?  Really?  I get that he is selfish and immature (constantly blaming others for what has happened to him), but his behaviour in the climactic scene is just over the top.  I found it difficult to suspend disbelief, especially when Pete also falls in love with the same books.  I love reading and have read some transformative books but . . .

Once again, Bill Hodges does not behave like a retired police officer.  In Mr. Mercedes, he doesn’t call the police when it would be appropriate to do so, and that proves to be a life-changing error.  Yet, he again does not alert police when a body is discovered?! 

This book is very much an awkward middle book in a trilogy.  Hodges visits Brady Hartsfield, the villain from Mr. Mercedes, in the hospital, and it is obvious that King wants to get to the third book which will undoubtedly include another conflict between the two. 

Again, I enjoyed the reading by Will Patton on the audiobook, but as an example of the detective story genre, this book is only mediocre. 

No comments:

Post a Comment