Ranked a Top Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Friday, November 20, 2026

Review of PARTITA by Barbara Kingsolver

4 Stars 

The novel begins with Livia Cable, a music teacher married to a farmer, receiving a phone call from Sigurd, a man with whom she’d had a passionate love affair thirty years earlier when she was studying music in university. He wants to see her, but Livia tells him she needs time to decide if she wants to see him.

The novel then moves back and forth through time. In the present, Livia is working on cleaning out her mother’s house after her death. The task is complicated by the fact that her mother, with whom she had a difficult relationship, was a hoarder. In the past we learn about her childhood, her brother Cyrus’ suicide, her desire to escape rural Tennessee to become a world-class pianist, her torrid relationship with a handsome socialist organizer until he shatters her world, and her career-ending injury.

The Livia Cable in the present and the Livia Bohusz in the past are very different. The young girl/woman is confident in her talent and ambitious though she is also naive. She falls in love with Sigurd, and to say that the affair with its “first-rate sex” is, for her at least, all-consuming is not an overstatement. Then she has to contend with two devastating events. The older Livia lives a much quieter life, a life the younger version would undoubtedly have seen as a failure. She seems content in her marriage to Charlie, but she describes it as “a marriage of simple comfort” in which sex is “Like putting a heating pad on an aching muscle.”

I’ve never studied classical music theory so there are sections where I missed a lot. I did learn that a partita is “a composition made of a lot of parts with different paces and moods.” The title clearly serves as a metaphor for life, but it also describes the novel: sometimes it offers quiet introspection and at other times, heated romance. And then there are the heart-breaking scenes.

I love dynamic characters so especially enjoyed seeing Livia’s growth. She sees her mother as a cruel monster; she tells her sister-in-law that she and her brother measured their days, “good or bad, based on which end of the belt she used against us.” When she starts going through her mother’s belongings, however, she learns things about her mother she never knew and they do change her feelings to some degree. She even comes to see she shares some similarities with her mother: a “bright dangerous stream . . . tipping us toward the extremes.”

It is what she learns about herself and her life that is most dramatic. She speaks of suffering with a type of phantom limb pain because parts of her life were gone and now her life is like “A house built on the sand of thwarted ambitions.” She realizes she too is a hoarder in her head: “’Full of blame, guilt, things I said or didn’t say, people I was mad at or that I thought were mad at me, that didn’t love me, or that I thought they didn’t love me enough . . . So much useless stuff.’” Charlie and his sister help Livia realize a simple thing can bring joy; it’s all a matter of perspective. She spent so much time blaming others for breaking her; only later does she realize she should credit herself for “putting the pieces back together.”

And that’s really what the novel is about: how a person can react to life-changing trauma. There are so many examples offered in the novel of how people have been damaged or have persevered: Cyrus, Livia’s mother, Charlie, and Livia. The message is that it is possible for a person to rebuild a life and find happiness even when one’s most cherished dreams have been crushed.

I would love a book devoted to Livia’s mother. There are so many questions about her past. She spoke of her wedding day as “’The day I slit my throat’”!? She never expressed love and certainly didn’t encourage her daughter’s musical ambitions. What Livia finds in her mother’s home suggests some explanations for her behaviour, but she and others can only speculate. Certainly there’s a suggestion of generational trauma which could be further explored and developed.

A Barbara Kingsolver novel is always a must-buy for me, and this book only confirms my opinion of her writing.

No comments:

Post a Comment