Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Tuesday, May 7, 2019

Review of THE BOOK WOMAN OF TROUBLESOME CREEK by Kim Michele Richardson (New Release)

3.5 Stars
This is an interesting historical novel.  It is a story about the blue-skinned people of Kentucky, the Kentucky Pack Horse Library Project, and life in Depression-era Appalachia. 

Nineteen-year-old Cussy Mary Carter (often called Bluet) is a book woman with the Pack Horse Project, delivering reading materials to the impoverished residents of rural eastern Kentucky in the mid-1930s.  Not only does her job involve physical hardship and danger, she also encounters prejudice because she suffers from methemoglobinemia which causes her to have blue skin.  Because of this inherited genetic condition, she is considered “coloured” and experiences psychological trauma and discrimination.  She isolates herself from most people, except her library patrons. 

Cussy is a fully developed character.  She has a passion for books and her job.  Though her job is not easy, she is determined to bring books to her patrons.  Though there are threats to her safety, she courageously continues her daily deliveries on very isolated routes.  When she encounters bigotry, she remains calm and civil.  Her kind nature has her taking time to read to people, and her generosity is obvious in her leaving food and medicine for people, even though she herself has little.  She does, however, have flaws.  Some of her actions are the result of pride and vanity, and her involvement in the hiding of a dead man makes her less than a perfect person.

Not only do readers learn about the Blues and pack horse librarians, they are also given an in-depth look at life in Appalachia in the 1930s.  The unremitting poverty of the people is shown.  We see their almost daily struggles with hunger.  Because they are isolated and cannot afford the services of a doctor, they rely on folk medicine.  Much of the dialogue is full of appropriate colloquialisms:  “’The young’uns won’t do their chores . . . Them books are doing that – surely making them lazy.  The girls are letting the laundry an’ sewing pile up around their ears, and the boys are reading at the creek when they ought to be fishing and working in the garden.  Plumb can’t get ‘em to work ‘cause they’s so busy sitting and reading them foolish books you’re bent on bringing.’” 

Cussy’s father is a coal miner so there is also considerable information about the conditions men like him endure, “working seventeen-hour days down on a rocky floor with bloody kneecaps in a black hole for scratch, and all the while fearing the next cave-in, the next blast that sends us to our fiery grave.”  The greediness of the mining companies is emphasized:  “The Company didn’t like for the Kentucky man to feel a dollar in his pocket, and they’d pay the miners most in Company scrip – credit that could only be used at the company store – to make sure of just that.  If a fellar balked at having to spend his pay there, he’d be dismissed right quick.  The Company also let workers draw on their earnings before payday, happy to give out scrip as loans with interest to keep the families good ‘n’ indebted to them.”
Cussy’s dad attends union meetings and she worries because “Those type of gatherings were as dangerous as cave-ins, explosions, and the miner’s lung, and what the Company feared and fought fiercely against. . . . [The Company would] shut the meetings down with threats and violence, burn a miner’s house or two, or make the leader of those talks disappear.”

As would be expected, the novel also focuses on the power of books and reading.  Cussy’s father objects to her job but she defends it strongly:  “’People are learning up there. . . . Books are the best way to do that- . . . folks tell me the books eases their burdens, it’s the best thing that could happen to them.’”    Cussy makes scrapbooks which she lends her patrons; those books are filled with recipes, sewing patterns and housecleaning tips which her readers might find useful.  The joy stories bring to children is shown during her visits to a school. 

Pacing is a bit problematic.  The book starts slowly so I found myself wondering if it was going to be a plodding read.  Then the ending is very abrupt; between the two last chapters, four years pass and much is left unexplained. 

The author seems to have tried to include something for everyone.  There is a romance element but there is also violence.  Cussy’s ever-so-loyal mule provides humour, as does Cussy’s encounter with moonshine.  The reader’s emotions are certainly aroused; parts are heartwarming but other parts are heartbreaking.  Personally, I found myself often angry at the narrow-mindedness and injustice.

I would certainly recommend this book to people who enjoy books about books and those who enjoy historical fiction which is the product of extensive research.  Those looking for a strong, female protagonist will also find one here.

Note:  I received a digital galley of this book from the publisher via NetGalley. 

No comments:

Post a Comment