Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Friday, July 5, 2019

Review of DreadfulWater by Thomas King

3.5 Stars
I loved the Dead Dog Café Comedy Hour when it was on CBC Radio about 20 years ago.  That radio comedy show was written by Thomas King so I shouldn’t have been surprised that he also wrote a mystery series with comedic elements.

Thumps DreadfulWater is a Cherokee ex-cop turned photographer who ends up becoming a detective.  A casino/condo complex is about to be opened when the body of a computer programmer is found on the premises.  Stick Merchant, a young activist opposed to the development, is the prime suspect so his mother Diane, the band chief and Thumps’ sometimes lover, asks Thumps to investigate.  As is expected, Thumps solves the case, though not before more murders occur. 

This is the first book of the series so there is considerable background given about Thumps.  He left the police force in Eureka, California, because of a tragedy after which “being a cop was something he could no longer do.”  He is now a photographer but considers himself “self-unemployed.”  One friend calls him lazy – “’the laziest man I’ve ever known’” – and napping does seem to be his favourite past-time.  That same friend also tells him that he is “’good at what you do’” and it does not come as a surprise that he is better at detective work than the sheriff, Duke Hockney. 

The touches of humour make the book an entertaining read.  There really isn’t the biting social and political satire I expected; chuckles are a more typical reaction to the light-hearted humour.  There are comments like “Trouble . . . was like a man, never in short supply, never too far away” and descriptions like a man having “no more romance than a Kleenex.”  Another character is introduced as “a skinny reed of a man who enjoyed complaining the way some people enjoy chocolate.  He was an uncomplicated, unrepentant mix of bigotry, sexism, and general vulgarity, a social garbage can on legs.”  About the most pointed comment is the reference to one man’s hatred of Native-Americans:  “That was the nice thing about hate . . . You didn’t have to be right.  You just had to be committed.”

The one element that had me puzzled was setting.  When Thumps left California, he moved east and he seems to be living somewhere in the northwest in a town named Chinook.  I think of King as a Canadian writer (though I know he is American by birth), but it becomes clear that the fictional Chinook is in the U.S. because the F.B.I. comes to investigate.  So what’s with the Tim Horton’s reference?  It and the mention of Calgary are an appeasement to Canadian readers?

This is a fast, non-taxing read.  The mystery is fairly straightforward and identifying the villain is not too difficult.  It is the sharp dialogue and witty exposition combined with the indigenous view of the world that make this book more than ordinary. 

                

No comments:

Post a Comment