Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski

Saturday, May 2, 2020

Review of MERCY HOUSE by Alena Dillon

3.5 Stars
Sister Evelyn and two other nuns have operated a shelter for abused women in Brooklyn for over 25 years when they and their unconventional methods come under scrutiny from the Catholic Church.  Their examiner is Bishop Robert Hawkins, a man with whom Sister Evelyn shares an unhappy history.  Some of their practices, the women know, the church would not condone.  Will the nuns’ forward-thinking approaches and the animosity between Sister Evelyn and Bishop Hawkins result in Mercy House being closed?

The novel focuses on Sister Evelyn, an elderly woman who has been a nun for 50 years.  She is kind and compassionate and utterly courageous in defending those in her care.  One of the residents of Mercy House tells her, “’Sister, you’re one badass bitch.’”  This feisty woman is, however, not perfect.  She has her flaws.  In encounters with the bishop, for example, she becomes meek and mild.  As she admits, she is guilty of the sin of pride, and her bitterness has tainted her relationships with her siblings. 

Sister Evelyn is a dynamic character who learns about herself.  She is older but proves to be capable of changing.  For instance, she realizes that she has held on to grudges for so long that they’ve turned into resentment:  “She’d opened Mercy House twenty-five years earlier, but was only just beginning to truly understand mercy and its value to the person who bestows it.” 

I appreciate the non-stereotypical portrayal of nuns.  They are shown to be real people.  One of the sisters practices Reiki.  They all have their indulgences.  They even use profane language occasionally.  One of them dares say, “’from my experience, the whole virginity thing is overstated.’”  Besides learning about the nuns, the reader learns about the women who have taken shelter at Mercy House.  Each of the current residents is given a chapter in which flashbacks reveal their backstories.  The situations of these women illustrate why Mercy House is needed and why a singular focus on religious conversion, which the church wants, may not be sufficient.    

The portrayal of Bishop Hawkins is problematic.  He is beyond despicable.  The nuns call him the Hawk, and Sister Evelyn describes him as “’a weasel, a mole man, a snake.’”  One of the residents tells him, “’You may have more degrees than a thermometer, but you’re ugly as hell . . . you arrogant mother-fucker.’”  He is too evil to be believable.  He has not one redeeming quality. 

Bishop Hawkins is used to criticize not Catholicism but the church.  The book discusses how the church squanders funds.  For instance, there is little respect for the lavish lifestyle of Pope Benedict:  “Pope Benedict XVI wore red velvet capes with ermine fur trim.  He commissioned his own cologne, which Evelyn called Pope-pourri.  He was chauffeured around in a Mercedes.  He had a personal library of more than twenty thousand books.  It took two hundred architects and engineers to restore his Rome palace, and he resided in his other palace while the construction was underway.” 

The book also focuses on abuse and the imbalance and misuse of power in the church:  “The Vatican had swept three thousand cases of priest pedophilia under the rug, protecting those criminals at the cost of their own morality and worldwide respect, but when it came to nuns, they wanted blood.”  The nuns are under the control of hypocritical priests who accuse nuns of immoral behaviour:  “’You tempted me, damn you. . . . These cassocks will need cleaning.  Consider it part of your penance.’”

The novel touches on very serious topics, but there are also touches of humour.  When replying to a question about how her manner of dress bears witness to the dignity and simplicity of her vocation, Sister Evelyn replies, “I try to keep body glitter to a minimum.  But I’m only human.”  At the end, before she heads off to battle an injustice, Evelyn thinks, “Knights took their trusty steeds into battle.  Evelyn would take a Honda Odyssey.  But if an Odyssey was good enough for Homer, she supposed it would be good enough for her.”

This book would make a good movie.  At different parts, it inspires tears, laughter, and out loud cheering. 

No comments:

Post a Comment