Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Tuesday, December 11, 2018

Review of MIDWINTER BREAK by Bernard MacLaverty

4 Stars
This quiet, reflective novel is a portrait of an ageing couple who have been married “for a protracted period.”  Gerry and Stella Gilmore travel to Amsterdam for a few days.  Gerry sees the trip as a holiday, but Stella has another agenda:  she wants to explore how “to live a more devout life,” a life which may not include Gerry whose excessive drinking troubles her.  They have many shared experiences and obviously love each other, but there are fissures in their relationship which may mean they will not be able to continue living as a couple. 

This is a tender, sympathetic examination of that relationship and the complexity of love.  Gerry and Stella love each other.  They hold hands, kiss whenever they’re alone in an elevator, and make love regularly.  Their familiar bantering suggests they enjoy each other’s company.  They even have the same mannerisms:  “Gerry joined his hands behind his back as he walked” while “Stella stood almost on tiptoe with her hands joined behind her back.”  Stella does things to make life easier for Gerry and he is attentive to her:  “her hand-eye co-ordination was a lot poorer than his, so generally he travelled behind her [on an escalator] in case she stumbled.  If they were descending he would go in front.”  Gerry’s extended interior monologue about what he knows Stella knows reads like a love poem, and the closing lines of the book may inspire tears. 

Nonetheless, there are problems.  Just as “nobody could peer into a relationship – even for a day or two – and come away with the truth,” Gerry looks at Stella and sees her “Like someone he did not fully know.”  This image is repeated:  “Seeing her as if he didn’t know her well” and “He was seeing her as someone he didn’t fully know.”  And Stella does not always help Gerry understand her; when he asks about a conversation she had with someone, she replies that it “’would be of little interest to you.’”  When she feels Gerry is dismissive of her views, she gets up and leaves, thereby dismissing his opinion. 

Gerry and Stella’s shared history includes a traumatic experience in Northern Ireland during The Troubles; that incident, which they do not directly discuss, affected them deeply.  They cope in different ways but their lack of communication means there are unresolved issues and a lack of understanding.   Gerry’s drinking is also driving a wedge between them; Gerry describes their “skidding off each other” and their becoming “ships that pass in the night.”   

The husband and wife are quite different in some ways.  Stella is very religious; she prays daily, attends Mass every Sunday, and is a Eucharistic minister in her parish.  In fact, “Her church was her everything” and she tells Gerry, “’Mass is the most precious thing in my life.’”  Gerry, however, is a non-believer who thinks religion is “’the greatest deception of our lives’” and often mocks Stella’s piety.  His devotion lies elsewhere:  “A poured, but as yet untouched, pint of Guinness has a slight dome to it which reminded him of the faint curvature of the outer wall of Burt Chapel.” 

This is not a plot-driven book.  There are no dramatic incidents except one event described in flashbacks.  It is very much a novel of character. Both are realistic characters with positive and negative qualities.  Gerry, for example, is not a caricature of a drunk, and Stella, though focused on living a good life, is not perfect.  Since the perspectives of both are given, the reader gets to know them better than they know each other. 

This understated novel about ordinary people with everyday frustrations is definitely worth a read.  It is relatively short, but with its careful attention to detail, it packs an emotional punch.

No comments:

Post a Comment