Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Sunday, March 10, 2019

Review of CAL by Bernard MacLaverty

4 Stars
I recently read Milkman by Anna Burns which is about an 18-year-old girl growing up in Northern Ireland.  This novella from 1983 is about a young man also living in Northern Ireland during The Troubles.

Cal McCluskey and his father Shamie are the only Catholics living in a Protestant area of Ulster.  Cal falls in love with Marcella, a young widow whose husband, a Protestant reserve policeman, was assassinated.  He hopes for a relationship with the local librarian but he has secrets because of his unwilling involvement with the IRA.  The book jacket offers a perfect summary:  “Springing out of the fear and violence of Ulster, Cal is a haunting love story in a land where tenderness and innocence can only flicker briefly in the dark.”

Cal’s father works in an abattoir where Cal could also have a job but he “hadn’t a strong enough stomach” (18).  It is quite obvious that the slaughterhouse is a metaphor for Ireland:  “People were dying every day, men and women were being crippled and turned into vegetables in the name of Ireland . . . [People were] caught between the jaws of two opposing ideals trying to grind each other out of existence” (83).  Cal has been coerced into being a driver during some militant actions but he doesn’t want to be involved:  “’I just don’t like what’s happening. . . . I have no stomach for it’” (23). 

The book depicts what life is like in a conflict zone.  Because of his neighbourhood, Cal faces almost daily intimidation, and he and his father receive a threat from the Ulster Volunteer Force:  “Get out you Fenian scum or we’ll burn you out.  This is your 2nd warning, there will be no other” (27).  Cal is a sensitive and thoughtful person who does not want to get involved but is pressured into being an accomplice for the IRA.  Then when he indicates that he wants out, he is threatened by those very people:  “’That creates a big problem, Cahal.  It would be out of my hands.  I wouldn’t like to see you hurt’” (40).  The effects on Shamie are equally devastating.

The characterization of Cal is outstanding.  He is a decent person who wants nothing to do with violence.  Yet he cannot live the peaceful life he wants or be with the woman he wants because of the sectarian violence.  He feels a great deal of shame and guilt for the activities in which he’s participated:  “Then he went to his bedroom to eat again the ashes of what he had done” (15).   

An atmosphere of sadness permeates the book.  The relationship between Cal and Marcella is doomed because of the circumstances.  This is a harrowing story told with compassion but without sentimentality.  It is a short narrative (154 pages) but its emotional effect lingers. 

No comments:

Post a Comment