Ranked a Top 25 Canadian Book Blog
Twitter: @DCYakabuski
Facebook: Doreen Yakabuski
Instagram: doreenyakabuski
Threads: doreenyakabuski
Substack: @doreenyakabuski
Bluesky: @dcyakabuski.bsky.social

Saturday, October 20, 2018

Review of THE SECRETS SHE KEEPS by Michael Robotham

3.5 Stars
After some serious books, I thought I’d read a thriller.  This author has won several crime writing awards so I thought I’d give him a try.

Agatha is a part-time grocery shelf stocker.  She is pregnant, but her boyfriend Hayden is away at sea with the Royal Navy and is ignoring her messages.    Agatha has become obsessed with Meghan, a woman who seems to have the perfect life:  a handsome husband, two beautiful children, a nice home, a group of sophisticated friends.  Meghan is also pregnant so Agatha is able to use this shared experience to befriend her.  This friendship ends up changing the lives of both women because Agatha is planning to steal something from Meghan. 

The book is narrated by both Agatha and Meghan in alternating chapters so the reader becomes privy to their thoughts and feelings.  It soon becomes clear that both women have secrets.  Agatha does not like discussing her past and Meghan has a secret which she is desperate to keep hidden.  Agatha’s voyeurism is disturbing but then Meghan’s life is not as glamourous as Agatha thinks. 

There are some plot elements that are a bit far-fetched, especially when it comes to men (Hayden, Simon) having changes of heart at the end.  Agatha’s planning is also almost flawless; her psychological profile suggests she has “a high degree of intelligence” but even with her meticulous planning the wheel-along upright shopping trolley used for the crime would easily catch police attention even if the colour is changed. 

What impressed me is the author’s ability to arouse sympathy for both women.   I found myself wanting each woman to get what she wants, though this is not possible.  Meghan does some stupid things but she doesn’t deserve what happens to her.  Agatha’s behaviour is definitely criminal but I agree with the psychologist who describes her as “’a victim.  Something dreadful has happened that prompted her into making some terrible decisions. . . . She has suffered enormously, which is why we have to show her compassion and understanding.’”

There is a message:  be grateful for what you have and don’t take the good things in your life for granted because “sometimes even the most charmed existence can change in the blink of an eye, or turn on the length of an eyelash.  One moment of indecision.  A cancer cell.  A rogue gene.  A wrong turn.  A red light.  A drunk driver.  A cruel piece of misfortune.” 

This is one of the better psychological thrillers I’ve read in some time.  Perhaps people with children should be warned that this is an intense read which touches on a parent’s worst nightmare.

No comments:

Post a Comment